A WRITER'S WIT |
MY BOOK WORLD
When I recently read Moby Dick for the second time in fifty years, a friend suggested that I peruse her copy of Philbrick’s book. The Essex’s tale of being rammed and sunk by an eighty-five foot sperm whale west of the Galapagos Islands is purportedly the story upon which author Herman Melville bases the climax of his novel: Captain Ahab’s battle with the white whale.
But as I recall, Melville seems to romanticize nineteenth century whaling, spending entire chapters on the minutiae of whaling equipment; Philbrick does not. The author develops Nantucket as a place whose character changes over the centuries. First, it is a quaint village, all houses similar and nicely taken care of by their successful merchant class, most with a “widow’s walk” on the roof where family members can keep an eye on the sea for when a ship such as the Essex has returned. When whaling dies out, the town does poorly. It is revived yet again in an era when it becomes a tourist trap, particularly during the summer months.
The narrative seems to come alive when the Essex is downed by the whale in Chapter 5. “Instead of fighting with its jaws and tail—the way whales commonly dispatched whaleboats—the Essex whale rammed the ship with its head, something that, Chase [first mate] insisted, ‘has never been heard of amongst the oldest and most experienced whalers.’ But what most impressed [him] was the remarkably astute way in which the bull employed its God-given battering ram. Both times the whale had approached the vessel from a direction ‘calculated to do us the most injury, by being made ahead, and thereby combining the speed of the two objects for the shock’” (89). At this point, the Essex’s tragedy is just beginning.
Spoiler: Through a series of events reflecting poor judgment, miscalculation, and mere bad luck, the crew of twenty load themselves onto three surviving whaleboats (used to actually attack and take down a whale) and attempt to make their way to the shores of Chile. Only two men ultimately survive, the captain and the first mate, both tending different whaleboats. The crew are so emaciated and weak that many die en route or after they make it to shore. This in spite of the fact that when one man would die of natural causes (the black sailors, who have the weakest constitutions to begin with because of poor lifelong nutrition, fail first), the remaining men would feast off the remains. And yet the nutrients would last but for a few hours before the crew members would become hungry again.
Philbrick is not the first author to write of the demise of the Essex. In the final sixty pages of the book—comprised of Notes, a Select Bibliography, Acknowledgements, and an Index—the author shares the telling of this story with many others who have told it and retold it from different points of view. These accounts include one from the captain, George Pollard, Jr., and one from the first mate Owen Chase.
The story of the Essex is one that abounds with wonder. Why does one whale take upon itself the aim of destroying this particular ship? Has the bull been attacked before and is now exacting revenge against our species? How do crew members survive the impact well enough to take off in three whaleboats, using only the most rudimentary procedures (i.e. dead reckoning) enabling them to make their way? Why would a ship be entrusted to a mediocre captain? And why would the first mate take advantage of the captain’s weaknesses for his own gain? How and why does this tale capture the imaginations of more readers than just the descendants of Nantucket for more than a century? Why, even now, does the saga keep someone like me reading for hours on end—as if I were again a fifth-grader lying on his bed whiling away a hot summer afternoon? Perhaps for the same reason I did so back then. To be carried away—without fear of drowning, myself—on one of the greatest seafaring mishaps in recorded history.
Up Next:
TUES: A Writer's Wit | Morley Callaghan
WEDS: A Writer's Wit | Jerry B. Jenkins
THURS: A Writer's Wit | Eleanor Catton
FRI: A Writer's Wit | Kristin Hannah
My Book World | Virginia Evans, The Correspondent

RSS Feed